In this week’s “Light Over Heat” video, I reflect on the significance of a moment in my interview with CNN’s John Avlon for his show Reality Check in which he asked me a question and I answered, “I don’t know.” This part of our pre-recorded interview was included in what was eventually broadcast. At first, I thought it made me look bad, but in retrospect I realized it taught an important lesson: the power and importance of saying “I don’t know.”
I am reminded of Jon Meacham’s commencement address at Wake Forest University a few years ago when he said reason requires that you accept you may be wrong. Reason also requires you to admit when you don’t know something rather than pretending to know everything. Both requirements facilitate light over heat.
The specific question Avlon asked concerned whether there had ever been broad-scale gun confiscation in the US. Certainly, we have never seen anything on the scale of England, Australia, or New Zealand. But friends pointed out a couple of moments to me:
*The Wounded Knee Massacre of 1890: 7th Cavalry Col. James Forsyth confiscates weapons from Miniconjou Lakota. Although not surprising, this would not be an example of confiscation of guns from US citizens, of course, since Native Americans were not granted citizenship until 1924.
*The New Orleans police confiscated guns from civilians during Hurricane Katrina in 2005.
Some associate “extreme risk protection orders” (i.e., red flag laws) with gun confiscation, though provided that due process is upheld, I do not see this as confiscation. Similarly, if someone goes from being a lawful gun owner to a prohibited person (e.g., they are convicted of a felony or are adjudicated mentally ill), then they should be required to surrender any firearms they own.
Even if we include ERPOs and newly prohibited persons, all of these examples are quite different than the kind of gun confiscation we saw in other countries wherein broad categories of firearms were banned and then taken back from the population. Of course, this doesn’t mean that it can’t happen here. It does mean that it hasn’t happened here.
Whether firearm registration is a precursor to confiscation is a significant question. It’s not possible to confiscate or “buy back” firearms if you don’t know who has them, as has been the case with New Zealand’s “mandatory buyback” of now banned semi-automatic rifles. The failure of individuals in New York State to register ownership of “assault style weapons” is also notable in this regard.
But I digress. My main point here is that our great gun debate might be improved if people on all sides every now and then just said “I don’t know.”
New “Light Over Heat” videos are released on YouTube every Wednesday, so please surf over to my YouTube channel and SUBSCRIBE to follow, RING THE BELL to receive notifications, and SHARE so others can learn about this work.